Comparing two groups of ranked objects by pairwise matching

Thumbnail Image
Date
1992
Authors
Liu, Jingyu
Major Professor
Advisor
H. A. David
Committee Member
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Altmetrics
Authors
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Organizational Unit
Statistics
As leaders in statistical research, collaboration, and education, the Department of Statistics at Iowa State University offers students an education like no other. We are committed to our mission of developing and applying statistical methods, and proud of our award-winning students and faculty.
Journal Issue
Is Version Of
Versions
Series
Department
Statistics
Abstract

Let [gamma][subscript]X = (X[subscript]sp(1)',X[subscript]sp(2)',...,X[subscript]sp(n)') and [gamma][subscript]Y = Y[subscript]sp(1)',Y[subscript]sp(2)',...,Y[subscript]sp(n)') be two groups of stochastically increasing rv's, which can represent, say, the increasing strengths of the members of two chess teams or two tennis teams, etc. Let [pi] = ([pi][subscript]1,[pi][subscript]2,...,[pi][subscript]n) be a permutation of (1,2,...,n). Then the statistic S([pi]) = [sigma][subscript]spi=1n I(Y[subscript]sp(i)' > X[subscript]sp(i)') measures the performance of [gamma][subscript]Y over [gamma][subscript]X under the permutation or matching [pi], where I(y > x) is an indicator function. We are interested in the relationship between [pi] and ES([pi]) = [sigma][subscript]spi = 1n P(Y[subscript]sp(i)' > X[subscript]sp([pi][subscript] i)'), especially in comparing ES([pi]) when [pi] = (1,2,..., n), corresponding to ordered matching, and when [pi] is randomly given. The P(Y[subscript]sp(i)' > X[subscript]sp(i)') are of interest in themselves. A class of special matchings called 'fair matchings' is emphasized. We say a matching [pi] is fair if ES([pi]) = n[over] 2 when [gamma][subscript]X ~ [gamma][subscript]Y. Simple matching and symmetric matching, which are fair under certain conditions, are also defined. The problems are investigated under two models, i.e., the order statistics model and the linear preference model;In the order statistics model, we assume that X[subscript]sp(i)' and Y[subscript]sp(i)' have the same marginal distributions as X[subscript](i) and Y[subscript](i), the i-th order statistics in two random samples of size n from F(x) and G(x), respectively. In this case, ES([pi]) = [sigma][subscript]spi = 1n P(Y[subscript](i) > X[subscript]([pi][subscript] i)), and when [pi] is randomly given ES([pi]) = [sigma][subscript]spi =1n P(Y[subscript]i > X[subscript]i), where (X[subscript]1,X[subscript]2,...,X[subscript]n) and (Y[subscript]1,Y[subscript]2,...,Y[subscript]n) are random samples from F(x) and G(x), respectively. If G(x) = F(x - [mu]), where [mu] ≥ 0, then it is shown that [sigma][subscript]spi = 1n P(Y[subscript](i) > X[subscript](i)) ≥ [sigma][subscript]spi = 1n P(Y[subscript]i > X[subscript]i). Moreover, we have [sigma][subscript]spi = 1n P(Y[subscript](i) > X[subscript](i)) ≥ ES([pi]), for any simple matching [pi]. If F(x) is a distribution function of a symmetric rv, then this inequality holds also for any symmetric matching [pi];In the linear preference model, we assume that X[subscript]sp(i)' ~ F(x - [lambda][subscript](i)) and Y[subscript]sp(i)' ~ F(x - [mu][subscript](i)), for i = 1,2,..., n, where F(x) is a unimodal distribution function, [lambda][subscript](1) ≤ [lambda][subscript](2) ≤ ... ≤ [lambda][subscript](n), and [mu][subscript](1) ≤ [mu][subscript](2) ≤ ... ≤ [mu][subscript](n). If U(x) is the cdf of Z[subscript]1 - Z[subscript]2, where Z[subscript]1 and Z[subscript]2 are iid with cdf F(x), the expectation of S([pi]) can be written as E[S([pi])] = [sigma][subscript]spi = 1n U([mu][subscript](i) - [lambda][subscript]([pi][subscript] i)). Under certain conditions, we get similar results to those in the order statistics model. We also obtain some other miscellaneous results about ordered matching, as well as maximization and rearrangement properties of ES([pi]).;In both models, the case with ties permitted is also considered.

Comments
Description
Keywords
Citation
Source
Subject Categories
Keywords
Copyright
Wed Jan 01 00:00:00 UTC 1992