Document Type

Article

Publication Version

Accepted Manuscript

Publication Date

8-7-2017

Journal or Book Title

Journal of Empirical Legal Studies

Volume

14

Issue

3

DOI

10.1111/jels.12156

Abstract

Two jury simulation experiments tested participants’ sensitivity to variations in the probative value of a piece of negative forensic evidence: failure to find gunshot residue (GSR) on a defendant alleged to have fired a gun. Experiment 1 found that if no GSR was detected, juries (N = 115) of undergraduates were appropriately less likely to convict a criminal defendant when the probability of detecting GSR was high than when it was low. Participants were unaffected by contextualizing expert testimony that emphasized either the value of the negative evidence for making inductive inferences or that the negative evidence was inconclusive for making deductions. Experiment 2 used a sample of venire jurors (N = 420) and manipulated the probability of detecting GSR (0 percent, 50 percent, 60 percent, 90 percent, or 100 percent) given that a gun was fired. Consistent with the first experiment, venire jurors were more likely to convict when the probability of detection was 0 percent or 50 percent than when it was 100 percent, but verdicts did not differ between the middle groups. This pattern of results suggests that jurors may evaluate negative evidence according to a fairly crude metric—giving it no weight if the probability of detection is zero, a great deal of weight if the probability of detection is 100 percent, and moderate weight if the probability of detection is somewhere in between.

Comments

This is a manuscript of an article published as Thompson, William C., Nicholas Scurich, Rachel Dioso‐Villa, and Brenda Velazquez. "Evaluating Negative Forensic Evidence: When Do Jurors Treat Absence of Evidence as Evidence of Absence?." Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 14, no. 3 (2017): 569-591. Posted with permission of CSAFE.

Copyright Owner

John Wiley & Sons, Ltd

Language

en

File Format

application/pdf

Published Version

Share

COinS