Justification and Ways of Believing

Thumbnail Image
Date
2002-05-01
Authors
Geirsson, Heimir
Major Professor
Advisor
Committee Member
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Authors
Person
Geirsson, Heimir
Department Chair
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Organizational Unit
Philosophy and Religious Studies
The Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies focuses on two areas of study. Its major in Philosophy seeks to examine human experience and reality through critical reflection and argument, developing skills in critical analysis and knowledge of ethics and philosophy. The major in Religious Studies seeks to investigate and reflect upon world religions in an objective, critical, and appreciative manner, providing students with knowledge of religion’s nature and its roles in social and individual life.
Journal Issue
Is Version Of
Versions
Series
Department
Philosophy and Religious Studies
Abstract

One of the issues that has been hotly discussed in connection with the direct designation theory is whether or not coreferential names can be substituted salva veritate in epistemic contexts. Some direct designation theorists believe that they can be so substituted. Some direct designation theorists and all Fregeans and neo-Fregeans believe that they cannot be so substituted. Fregeans of various stripes have used their intuition against free substitution to argue against the direct designation theory. Some direct designation theorists have used the same intuitions to argue against the view that belief reports of simple declarative sentences can be accounted for with singular propositions. This paper has two main goals; first, to show that the discussion of the issue has tended to treat all epistemic contexts equally, and second, to argue that we should not treat substitutions in contexts that involve justification (and hence knowledge) in the same way as we treat substitution in simple belief contexts, i.e., contexts that just involve the belief relation.

Comments

This article is published as Geirsson, H., Justification and Ways of Believing. Gisputatio., 12(2002); 43-53. Posted with permission.

Description
Keywords
Citation
DOI
Source
Copyright
Tue Jan 01 00:00:00 UTC 2002
Collections